{"id":972,"cve":"CVE-2022-24787","cve_url":"https:\/\/www.cvedetails.com\/cve\/CVE-2022-24787","cwe":"CWE-697: Insufficient Comparison","cwe_number":697,"cwe_url":"https:\/\/cwe.mitre.org\/data\/definitions\/697","cvss_score":7.5,"published":"2022-04-04","owasp":"A05 Security Misconfiguration","odc":"Function","cdc":"Incorrect Functionality","category":"Information Leakage","subcategory":"Insecure Handling of Sensitive Data","scope":"Remote","impact":"Information Disclosure","summary":"Vyper v0.3.1 and earlier: Dirty bytes","permalink":"https:\/\/netpack.pt\/vaitp\/vulnerability\/CVE-2022-24787\/","description":"Vyper is a Pythonic Smart Contract Language for the Ethereum Virtual Machine. In version 0.3.1 and prior, bytestrings can have dirty bytes in them, resulting in the word-for-word comparisons giving incorrect results. Even without dirty nonzero bytes, two bytestrings can compare to equal if one ends with `\"\\x00\"` because there is no comparison of the length. A patch is available and expected to be part of the 0.3.2 release. There are currently no known workarounds.","solution":"Update to Vyper version 0.3.2 or later","affected_component":"Vyper","fixed_by_upgrading":true,"vulnerable_code":"# VULNERABILITY DEMONSTRATION\n# Description: Vyper v0.3.1 and earlier: Dirty bytes...\n# This code demonstrates the security vulnerability\n\nimport os\nimport sys\n\ndef vulnerable_function():\n    \"\"\"Demonstrates the vulnerability with comprehensive example\"\"\"\n    try:\n        # Original vulnerable implementation:\n        def bytestring_compare(a: bytes, b: bytes) -> bool:\n    return a == b\n\na = b\"example\\x00\"\nb = b\"example\"\n\nresult = bytestring_compare(a, b)\n        \n        # Additional vulnerable patterns that demonstrate the issue:\n        user_input = input(\"Enter data: \")  # Dangerous: no validation\n        \n        # Multiple security issues present:\n        # 1. No input sanitization\n        # 2. No bounds checking  \n        # 3. No error handling\n        # 4. Information disclosure possible\n        \n        if user_input:\n            # Unsafe processing without validation\n            processed = str(user_input) * 100  # Can cause DoS\n            result = processed.upper().lower()  # Inefficient processing\n            \n            # Potential information leakage\n            return {\n                \"result\": result,\n                \"length\": len(result),\n                \"input_type\": type(user_input).__name__,\n                \"system_info\": os.name  # Information disclosure\n            }\n        \n        return {\"error\": \"No input provided\"}\n    \n    except Exception as e:\n        # Vulnerable error handling - information leakage\n        return {\n            \"error\": f\"Processing failed: {e}\",\n            \"input\": str(user_input) if 'user_input' in locals() else None,\n            \"traceback\": str(e.__traceback__)  # Information disclosure\n        }\n\ndef additional_vulnerable_example():\n    \"\"\"Additional example showing the vulnerability\"\"\"\n    # This function demonstrates why the vulnerability is dangerous\n    data = []\n    \n    # Vulnerable loop without bounds\n    for i in range(1000000):  # Can cause DoS\n        data.append(f\"item_{i}\")  # Memory exhaustion possible\n    \n    return len(data)\n\n# Example of how this vulnerability could be exploited:\n# 1. Provide malicious input to cause DoS\n# 2. Extract system information through error messages  \n# 3. Cause memory exhaustion through unbounded operations\n# 4. Information disclosure through verbose error handling","patched_code":"# SECURE IMPLEMENTATION\n# Description: Vyper v0.3.1 and earlier: Dirty bytes...\n# This code demonstrates the secure fix for the vulnerability\n\nimport os\nimport sys\nimport re\nimport logging\nfrom typing import Any, Dict, Optional, Union\n\nclass SecureProcessor:\n    \"\"\"Secure implementation with comprehensive protection measures\"\"\"\n    \n    def __init__(self, max_input_size: int = 10000, max_processing_time: int = 30):\n        self.max_input_size = max_input_size\n        self.max_processing_time = max_processing_time\n        \n        # Setup secure logging\n        logging.basicConfig(level=logging.WARNING)\n        self.logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)\n    \n    def secure_function(self, user_input: Any = None) -> Optional[Dict[str, Any]]:\n        \"\"\"Secure implementation with comprehensive validation\"\"\"\n        try:\n            # Input validation layer 1: Existence check\n            if user_input is None:\n                raise ValueError(\"Input is required\")\n            \n            # Input validation layer 2: Type checking\n            if not isinstance(user_input, (str, int, float)):\n                raise ValueError(\"Invalid input type\")\n            \n            # Input validation layer 3: Size limits\n            input_str = str(user_input)\n            if len(input_str) > self.max_input_size:\n                raise ValueError(\"Input too large\")\n            \n            # Input validation layer 4: Content sanitization\n            sanitized_input = self._sanitize_input(input_str)\n            \n            # Secure processing with bounds checking\n            processed = self._process_safely(sanitized_input)\n            \n            # Output validation\n            if not self._validate_output(processed):\n                raise ValueError(\"Output validation failed\")\n            \n            # Return secure result (no sensitive information)\n            return {\n                \"result\": processed,\n                \"status\": \"success\",\n                \"length\": len(processed) if processed else 0\n            }\n            \n        except ValueError as e:\n            # Secure error handling - no information leakage\n            self.logger.warning(f\"Input validation failed: {type(e).__name__}\")\n            return {\n                \"result\": None,\n                \"status\": \"error\",\n                \"message\": \"Invalid input provided\"\n            }\n        except Exception as e:\n            # Generic error handling - minimal information\n            self.logger.error(f\"Processing error: {type(e).__name__}\")\n            return {\n                \"result\": None,\n                \"status\": \"error\", \n                \"message\": \"Processing failed\"\n            }\n    \n    def _sanitize_input(self, input_str: str) -> str:\n        \"\"\"Sanitize input to prevent injection attacks\"\"\"\n        # Remove potentially dangerous characters\n        sanitized = re.sub(r'[<>&\"\\']', '', input_str)\n        \n        # Remove control characters\n        sanitized = re.sub(r'[\\x00-\\x1f\\x7f-\\x9f]', '', sanitized)\n        \n        # Normalize whitespace\n        sanitized = re.sub(r'\\s+', ' ', sanitized).strip()\n        \n        # Length limit after sanitization\n        return sanitized[:1000]\n    \n    def _process_safely(self, input_data: str) -> str:\n        \"\"\"Process data safely with bounds checking\"\"\"\n        if not input_data:\n            return \"\"\n        \n        # Safe processing with limits\n        # Instead of multiplying by 100, use safe operations\n        processed = input_data.upper()\n        \n        # Limit processing operations\n        if len(processed) > 5000:\n            processed = processed[:5000]\n        \n        return processed\n    \n    def _validate_output(self, output: Any) -> bool:\n        \"\"\"Validate output for security\"\"\"\n        if output is None:\n            return True\n        \n        if isinstance(output, str):\n            # Check output size\n            if len(output) > 50000:\n                return False\n            \n            # Check for suspicious content\n            if any(char in output for char in '<>&\"\\''):\n                return False\n        \n        return True\n    \n    def secure_additional_processing(self) -> Dict[str, int]:\n        \"\"\"Secure additional processing with resource limits\"\"\"\n        try:\n            # Original patched implementation:\n            def bytestring_compare(a: bytes, b: bytes) -> bool:\n    if len(a) != len(b):\n        return False\n    return a == b\n\na = b\"example\\x00\"\nb = b\"example\"\n\nresult = bytestring_compare(a, b)\n            \n            # Enhanced secure processing:\n            data = []\n            max_items = 1000  # Reasonable limit\n            \n            # Bounded loop with resource monitoring\n            for i in range(min(max_items, 1000)):\n                # Check if we should continue\n                if len(data) >= max_items:\n                    break\n                \n                # Safe item creation\n                item = f\"secure_item_{i}\"\n                data.append(item)\n                \n                # Memory usage check (simplified)\n                if sys.getsizeof(data) > 1024 * 1024:  # 1MB limit\n                    break\n            \n            return {\n                \"items_created\": len(data),\n                \"memory_safe\": True,\n                \"bounded_execution\": True\n            }\n            \n        except Exception as e:\n            self.logger.error(f\"Secure processing error: {type(e).__name__}\")\n            return {\n                \"items_created\": 0,\n                \"memory_safe\": True,\n                \"error\": \"Processing failed safely\"\n            }\n\n# Secure usage examples:\nprocessor = SecureProcessor(max_input_size=5000)\n\n# Safe input processing\nresult1 = processor.secure_function(\"safe input data\")\nresult2 = processor.secure_function(12345)\n\n# Safe additional processing  \nadditional_result = processor.secure_additional_processing()\n\n# Security features implemented:\n# 1. Comprehensive input validation\n# 2. Size and resource limits\n# 3. Content sanitization\n# 4. Secure error handling (no information leakage)\n# 5. Output validation\n# 6. Bounded operations (no DoS)\n# 7. Memory usage monitoring\n# 8. Secure logging for monitoring","payload_needed":false,"payload":null,"payload_status":"none","published_fix":[{"repository":"vyperlang\/vyper","commit_url":"https:\/\/github.com\/vyperlang\/vyper\/commit\/2c73f8352635c0a433423a5b94740de1a118e508","commit_subject":"Merge pull request from GHSA-7vrm-3jc8-5wwm","units":[{"file":"vyper\/codegen\/core.py","function":"copy_bytes"},{"file":"vyper\/codegen\/expr.py","function":null},{"file":"vyper\/codegen\/expr.py","function":"Expr.parse_Compare"},{"file":"vyper\/codegen\/keccak256_helper.py","function":null},{"file":"vyper\/codegen\/keccak256_helper.py","function":"keccak256_helper"}]}],"references":"https:\/\/bandit.readthedocs.io\/en\/latest\/blacklists\/blacklist_imports.html"}